Soldiers who have tasted the brine of combat understand this, which is why they get so angry when someone disrespects the flag. This country is the value, what we value is the value, and often, that’s as specific as one can get.

Soldiers who have tasted the brine of combat understand this, which is why they get so angry when someone disrespects the flag. This country is the value, what we value is the value, and often, that’s as specific as one can get.

On the eve of the seventh-year anniversary of the deaths of paratroopers PFC Michael Metcalf and 1LT Jonathan Walsh, whose demise by IED I detailed in my book The Brave Ones: A Memoir of Hope, Pride, and Military Service, a reader sent an email disagreeing with my analysis.

 

In my book I write:

 

“The bereaved parents that I would speak with after the deployment often wanted to know what the objective was for the mission their son died on. ‘What has the army traded for my son’s life?’ Yet war rarely affords a fair value, or even any value, to the individual life. Soldiers who have tasted the brine of combat understand this, which is why they get so angry when someone disrespects the flag. This country is the value, what we value is the value, and often, that’s as specific as one can get.”

 

The critical reader, son of an officer who was with the 8thAir Force on D-Day and himself, a Vietnam-era Air Force veteran, writes, “Perhaps, in a war protecting America, but not Vietnam, Iraq, or Afghanistan (our son has deployed three times), perhaps, even Korea. What a waste and how wrong . . . the truncated lives, single parents, kids without parents and the money, too, not lost for this country. Your book strengthens my conviction… Here America is, almost 70 years after the beginning of the Korean “Conflict” and about 60 years after the beginning of Vietnam, and Americans are still dying for politicians!”

 

His wasn’t a question, only an opinion – a reaction – that he felt compelled to share. Yet for the veterans of America’s longest war, the only war we’ve conducted in which a child not yet born when the war began can now serve in the same war as his father or mother, the sacrifices made in Afghanistan are a burning irritant. In Qara Bagh where Walsh and Metcalf were killed, Afghan forces and the Taliban are still battling for control of Highway 1. What had they died for?

 

The day his email arrived, I happened to be spending the day with a Marine veteran of the Battle of Khe Sanh, a bilateral amputee infantryman of the Iraq War whose life is dedicated to service members suffering from the wounds of war, and an Army officer who had led soldiers in the slums of Sadr City and was an infantry company commander in the same battalion as Walsh and Metcalf when they were killed. I also emailed a favorite command sergeant major on active duty with the 82nd, one who had escaped the communists in Vietnam and emigrated to America. I asked each their opinion of the man’s statement, “What a waste and how wrong.”

 

None of them answered quickly. When they finally did, I was struck by the consistency of what that had to say. Here then is their reply to the Air Force vet’s comment.

 

1) There is rarely a simple answer to the worth of combat deaths. Were the 2,336 American KIA and 8,450 WIA on the strategically unimportant island of Peleliu during World War II a waste, or somehow necessary to the defeat of Imperial Japan? Depends on who you ask.

 

2) The Air Force vet is fortunate that he can criticize the State in an email and not pay a price for it, either immediately or long-term. As Americans, we take that for granted, as do free peoples from countries that have benefited from the projection of American power since his father flew with the Mighty Eighth over Normandy and Berlin. 

 

3) Hind-sight gives much-improved accuracy and the ability to criticize those who made the calls on difficult decisions in war, and ultimately, the “worth” of any particular action.

 

4) Regarding American lives lost "for the country," it's common knowledge among front-line warriors that lives are risked in defense of a brother or sister, and only tangentially for country. That said, America asks citizens to vote for representatives and an executive. She asks these politicians to make good decisions based on what the citizenry want, or they get voted out. She asks the soldier to defend her. It seems the weak link there is the citizen. Not sure how the soldier's life is wasted, then, if he fights well for the man on his left and right. If he does so, his forfeited life is not a waste to him. The man’s family – either man’s family – may feel differently.

 

Regarding politicians, who likes them? Yes, we need to keep their feet to the fire so we (and the rest of the free world whose defense is subsidized by the US military) don't end up facing the very worst of human nature here at home.

 

I told the reader he has every right to believe that the 70 thousand lives lost during and since the Vietnam War were a waste, or not in service to country, if he so chooses. He is free to believe what he wants and speak his mind freely. So am I. I think it was a waste of life for COL Greg Townsend, who survived multiple deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan with our unit, to get killed this past Easter Weekend – seven years to the day that Walsh and Metcalf were killed – when he pulled over to help a stranded motorist on Route 460 in Virginia and the car jack failed, crushing Greg underneath.

 

I’m still pretty sure COL Townsend would not have regretted helping the stranger because that's the man Greg was.

 

If they had a vote, perhaps those who have lost their lives in recent wars would agree with the skeptical Air Force veteran that their lives were wasted. Maybe they wouldn't. At least we, the living, might consider that their intentions for their own lives counted.

 

SGT MAC

Note about the Author: Michael J. MacLeod is a former US Army paratrooper who served with the 82nd Airborne Division from 2008-2013 as a combat correspondent. He is one of the most published military journalists of the last decade and has won dozens of journalism awards including the Army’s 2012 Military Journalist of the Year. For his work during deployment, MacLeod was awarded the Bronze Star Medal, an award normally reserved for soldiers of much higher rank. 

You can read his full book here:

https://www.amazon.com/Brave-Ones-Memoir-Military-Service-ebook/dp/B00Y0AJVAQ

 

  • 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment - The Night Stalkers
    160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment - The Night Stalkers

    They were born out of a doomed operation, but their role has become irreplaceable. Their brothers in arms count on them in the most difficult of times while they remain the enemy’s worst nightmare. Battle-proven, always resilient, and lethal, they are highly respected among all the services and have often...

    Read More
  • Operation Hump: 173rd’s Legendary Operation in Vietnam
    Operation Hump: 173rd’s Legendary Operation in Vietnam

      Soldiers take cover in a crater during the Vietnam War (Courtesy Photo/U.S. Army) Operation Hump is a legendary operation conducted jointly by Australian and American Airborne forces in Vietnam. The Friendly composition consisted of the 1st Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment, 173rd Airborne Brigade, as well as a battalion from...

    Read More
  • The Elusive Blue Air Assault Beret
    The Elusive Blue Air Assault Beret

    Blue Air Assault Berets: A Brief Chapter in Military History In the accounts of military tradition, berets have often stood out as symbols of honor and excellence, providing soldiers with an extra element of pride. They adorn soldiers' heads, signifying their commitment to a unique calling. While everyone in the...

    Read More
  • Wisdom from the Community: Top Five Pieces of Advice for New Paratroopers
    Wisdom from the Community: Top Five Pieces of Advice for New Paratroopers

    Wisdom from the Community: Top Five Pieces of Advice for New Paratroopers Hear ye, hear ye! Young paratroopers, we believe you deserve some valuable advice because you are at a stage where you need it to shape your military career. Because we care, we reached out to our community to...

    Read More
  • Operation Restore Democracy: The Landing that Never Happened
    Operation Restore Democracy: The Landing that Never Happened

    Operation Restore Democracy: The Landing that Never Happened In the early 1990s, Haiti's democracy was in constant crisis, and the island was being governed by unconstitutional leadership. The regimes kept changing but lacked national and international legitimacy, leading to U.N. sanctions. The United States created a multinational force (MNF) to...

    Read More
  • The Evolution of Airborne Operations: From World War II to Present Day
    The Evolution of Airborne Operations: From World War II to Present Day

    They called it "The Iron Rain." On the fateful day of June 6, 1944, as part of Operation Overlord, more than 13,000 paratroopers from the American 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions leaped into the night sky, their hearts racing, their minds set on one goal: the liberation of Europe from...

    Read More
  • Boots On Ground: The 82nd Airborne in the Battle for Iraq
    Boots On Ground: The 82nd Airborne in the Battle for Iraq

    Transporting you from your favorite reading nook literally into the boots of the 82nd Airborne in the Battle for Iraq, Boots on the Ground by Karl Zinsmeister details the story of the frontline in a way that often isn't covered in the headline news story.  A frontline reporter traveling with the 82nd,...

    Read More
  • The Essentials: The C-17 Globemaster
    The Essentials: The C-17 Globemaster

    "The Essentials" Series is a monthly blog related to Airborne culture. We target fundamental topics such as Airborne equipment, culture, traditions, trivia, etc. While we have a semi-annual plan on the topics, we remain open to ideas from paratroopers like yourself. So, feel free to reach out and propose a...

    Read More
  • The Filthy Thirteen: The True Story of the Dirty Dozen
    The Filthy Thirteen: The True Story of the Dirty Dozen

    Tightly bound to one another in times of war, unforgiving in the way they approach a battle, and legendary in their bravery, the story is told of the US paratroopers of the US 101st Airborne Division in The Filthy Thirteen. Finding the courage to parachute behind enemy lines in the...

    Read More
  • Battle of Yongju: The Battle of the Apple Orchard
    Battle of Yongju: The Battle of the Apple Orchard

    Also known as the Battle of the Apple Orchard, the UN orchestrated the Battle of Yongju to fight back against the North Korean forces during the Korean war. In this offensive maneuver, the US 187th Airborne Regimental Combat Team—or the US 187 RCT was called on to move in front...

    Read More
  • The Chosen Few: US Paratrooper's Battle in Eastern Afghanistan
    The Chosen Few: US Paratrooper's Battle in Eastern Afghanistan

    Bringing you to a more recent battle in a different part of the world, The Chosen Few by Gregg Zoroya is a detailed account of how a U.S. Paratroopers company fought in eastern Afghanistan in 2007. In hopes to go in on a single, swift mission in order to befriend the isolated...

    Read More
  • No Better Place To Day: The Battle For La Fiere Bridge
    No Better Place To Day: The Battle For La Fiere Bridge

    In this first-person narrative, Robert M. Murphy transports you right into the battle at La Fiere in the early morning hours of D-Day.  Taking you through a firsthand account of close-quarters combat in the industrial war of the 20th century, Murphy covers all sides of the war, from the paratroopers...

    Read More
  • Airborne Equipment: The Waco CG-4A Glider
    Airborne Equipment: The Waco CG-4A Glider

    During World War II, the U.S. Army Air Forces utilized military gliders as a method of delivery to battle. These one-time use, engineless aircraft were towed in pairs near to the front lines of battle, typically by a Douglas C-47 military transport aircraft, carrying troops or supplies to bolster advancing...

    Read More
  • Over 100 years of bravey: The 173rd Airborne Brigade
    Over 100 years of bravey: The 173rd Airborne Brigade

    The 173rd Airborne Brigade is a United States Army airborne infantry brigade formed on 12 June 1917 at Camp Devens, Massachusetts. It is one of the oldest airborne units in the United States Army and has a rich history of service and combat operations. A WORLD AT WAR During World...

    Read More
  • War: Through the eyes of the 173rd Airborne in Afghanistan
    War: Through the eyes of the 173rd Airborne in Afghanistan

    "Brotherhood has nothing to do with feelings; it has to do with how you define your relationship to others. It has to do with the rather profound decision to put the welfare of the group above your personal welfare. In such a system, feelings are meaningless. In such a system,...

    Read More
  • Into The Viper's Nest: The First Pivotal Battle Of The Afghan War
    Into The Viper's Nest: The First Pivotal Battle Of The Afghan War

    "I set out then to report this story from many points of view - American and British, from soldier to general, from diplomat to president. It seemed to me that only by getting behind the scenes could anyone pretend to understand what was happening. And it seemed far better to...

    Read More
  • You can Jump from a plane. How about jumping into a book?
    You can Jump from a plane. How about jumping into a book?

    As paratroopers, we know you've got discipline and are always on the lookout for that new book title that will leave a lasting impression. The global library has never been more diverse, yet you want something you can relate to. The good news is that we've reached out to our...

    Read More
Back to blog