Five Years Ago, we were “Lying to Ourselves.” Is the Army still doing it?

In February 2015, the Strategic Studies Institute and the U.S. Army War College Press published a report that sent shockwaves throughout the officer corps. Lying to Ourselves: Dishonesty in the Army Profession outlined in brutal detail a “culture of dishonesty” within the Army and the organizational failures that nurtured it.
For years after its publication, the report was discussed and thoroughly chewed on during OPDs and NCOPDs alike. Heads nodded in agreement; the constant tide of mandatory training was bemoaned; senior commanders swore up and down not to propagate the “zero tolerance for failure” climate that fed the issue.
But did things change?
Let’s start with a quick reminder. In broad strokes, the 2015 report offers recommendations for combating the culture of deceit within the Army.
Firstly, we must acknowledge the problem that exists both on the organizational and personal level. Secondly, they recommend exercising restraint and giving an eye of scrutiny towards mandatory training and limiting how commands feed the “good idea fairy.” Lastly, the report suggests that the Army must “lead truthfully.” This means senior leaders should be standing up to political appointees and officials who want more training on the latest hot-button issue. This also means reporting honestly and taking the potential consequences of doing so. One must be willing, at times, to fall on their sword for the sake of reporting truthfully.
The issue, however, is not just mandatory training taking more time than is available. The problem is Army-wide and in multiple areas. Look within your formations. Do you have a Supply Sergeant who answers, “you don’t want to know,” when asked where extra parts and equipment came from? Was all the required 350-1 training really completed before block leave? Did a the 40-hour annual service on a HMMWV take 40 hours, or was it pencil-whipped? Was the service packet for that vehicle filled out to demonstrate as such?
Now while I’ve slept comfortably under my DD214 blanket for several years, I can still vividly remember my time as a staff officer and a company commander. Gather round kids, time to crack open the Former Captain’s Logs for story time.
The year? 2015. The place? Fort Hood. Two of the larger sustainment units on post deployed their headquarters elements. This left about a dozen or so companies in need of signature authority. Our brigade support battalion was assigned six of these companies. Now, usually, this meant that those companies would keep doing business as usual, and things requiring battalion signature would get forwarded to us.
That was not the case.
Due to some, if I’m going to be brutally honest, OER bullet hunting by our BC, those six units were completed shuffled to our battalion. Our battalion grew to nine companies and over 1,000 troops. We were, effectively, not a CSSB in size.
During this transition, the additional duty officers of our battalion were required to inspect these six companies to ensure they were up to standard: Safety, Environmental Compliance, EO, the works. You can already see where this is going.
No one thought this was an effective use of time, and inspections went as you would expect them to. On the spot, corrections ruled the day, and all of these companies passed with flying colors in near-record time.
Fast forward several months. Battalion staff duty is now inspecting nine companies worth of Arms Rooms spread across the post. How many times do you think the duty officer came through and conducted the before and after midnight inspections at the same time?
Many of you reading this are likely saying to yourselves, “yeah, of course, that happened.” Some of you might even suggest that these things aren’t that big of a deal. Everyone does it. You’re spending less time on nonsense and spending more time on things that are actually mission essential.
That’s the point of the report. This kind of attitude is ubiquitous. It is ingrained into the very culture of our bureaucracy.
So where do we go from there? Did things change in the five years since that report was published?
Fortunately, the report brought to light what many leaders and subordinates alike bemoaned. There was too much mandatory training. With only so much time to train, something had to give. Sometimes that something was readiness. Sometimes it was honesty. Either way, something had to be done.
Enter Army Directive 2018-07, Prioritizing Efforts - Readiness and Lethality and the seven updates that followed. The Secretary of the Army cut a large swatch through the mandatory training list, making multiple items no longer required by HQDA. Several of HQDA’s worst offenders were eliminated. TRiPS, the SLRRT, the Accident Avoidance Course, and many others met the chopping block. These measures undoubtedly helped, but were they enough?
While a reduction in training is definitely helpful, both the report and our collective experience tell us that it’s more than mandatory training that creates this duplicity culture. When human nature’s desire to find the “path of least resistance” meets the Army’s nature as an organization, there will be the desire and temptation to cut corners and prioritize one thing over another.
The Army, at least during my time, has many competing cultures and belief systems. There is, of course, the Army Values and the moral/ethical guidelines we should live by. There is the desire to place the mission above all else, the inherent drive to be “more hooah” or “harder” than other units, and (among other things) the issues of personal ego, ambition, and pride.
We need only look at Battalion Commanders who need a feather in their cap to make full bird, Command Sergeants Major who think modern problems require Vietnam era solutions, and the age-old stereotype of the invisible and somehow magical Chief Warrant Officers to see that the fuel for this fire still very much exists.
Take the current Coronavirus issue, for example. In order to “improve readiness,” many commanders are trying to shoehorn gunnery tables and other types of training into their schedules – all the while creating a situation which can lead to the spread of that virus, removing some Soldiers from the formation for health reasons, and thereby reducing readiness all in the same stroke.
These aren’t HQDA decisions but unit-level leadership ones. Big Army has made strides towards fixing the issues highlighted in this nowfive-year-old report, but it is up to leaders at the unit level to carry it the rest of the way.
Recent Articles
-
160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment - The Night Stalkers
They were born out of a doomed operation, but their role has become irreplaceable. Their brothers in arms count on them in the most difficult of times while they remain the enemy’s worst nightmare. Battle-proven, always resilient, and lethal, they are highly respected among all the services and have often...
-
Operation Hump: 173rd’s Legendary Operation in Vietnam
Soldiers take cover in a crater during the Vietnam War (Courtesy Photo/U.S. Army) Operation Hump is a legendary operation conducted jointly by Australian and American Airborne forces in Vietnam. The Friendly composition consisted of the 1st Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment, 173rd Airborne Brigade, as well as a battalion from...
-
The Elusive Blue Air Assault Beret
Blue Air Assault Berets: A Brief Chapter in Military History In the accounts of military tradition, berets have often stood out as symbols of honor and excellence, providing soldiers with an extra element of pride. They adorn soldiers' heads, signifying their commitment to a unique calling. While everyone in the...
-
Wisdom from the Community: Top Five Pieces of Advice for New Paratroopers
Wisdom from the Community: Top Five Pieces of Advice for New Paratroopers Hear ye, hear ye! Young paratroopers, we believe you deserve some valuable advice because you are at a stage where you need it to shape your military career. Because we care, we reached out to our community to...
-
Operation Restore Democracy: The Landing that Never Happened
Operation Restore Democracy: The Landing that Never Happened In the early 1990s, Haiti's democracy was in constant crisis, and the island was being governed by unconstitutional leadership. The regimes kept changing but lacked national and international legitimacy, leading to U.N. sanctions. The United States created a multinational force (MNF) to...
-
The Evolution of Airborne Operations: From World War II to Present Day
They called it "The Iron Rain." On the fateful day of June 6, 1944, as part of Operation Overlord, more than 13,000 paratroopers from the American 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions leaped into the night sky, their hearts racing, their minds set on one goal: the liberation of Europe from...
-
Boots On Ground: The 82nd Airborne in the Battle for Iraq
Transporting you from your favorite reading nook literally into the boots of the 82nd Airborne in the Battle for Iraq, Boots on the Ground by Karl Zinsmeister details the story of the frontline in a way that often isn't covered in the headline news story. A frontline reporter traveling with the 82nd,...
-
The Essentials: The C-17 Globemaster
"The Essentials" Series is a monthly blog related to Airborne culture. We target fundamental topics such as Airborne equipment, culture, traditions, trivia, etc. While we have a semi-annual plan on the topics, we remain open to ideas from paratroopers like yourself. So, feel free to reach out and propose a...
-
The Filthy Thirteen: The True Story of the Dirty Dozen
Tightly bound to one another in times of war, unforgiving in the way they approach a battle, and legendary in their bravery, the story is told of the US paratroopers of the US 101st Airborne Division in The Filthy Thirteen. Finding the courage to parachute behind enemy lines in the...
-
Battle of Yongju: The Battle of the Apple Orchard
Also known as the Battle of the Apple Orchard, the UN orchestrated the Battle of Yongju to fight back against the North Korean forces during the Korean war. In this offensive maneuver, the US 187th Airborne Regimental Combat Team—or the US 187 RCT was called on to move in front...
-
The Chosen Few: US Paratrooper's Battle in Eastern Afghanistan
Bringing you to a more recent battle in a different part of the world, The Chosen Few by Gregg Zoroya is a detailed account of how a U.S. Paratroopers company fought in eastern Afghanistan in 2007. In hopes to go in on a single, swift mission in order to befriend the isolated...
-
No Better Place To Day: The Battle For La Fiere Bridge
In this first-person narrative, Robert M. Murphy transports you right into the battle at La Fiere in the early morning hours of D-Day. Taking you through a firsthand account of close-quarters combat in the industrial war of the 20th century, Murphy covers all sides of the war, from the paratroopers...
-
Airborne Equipment: The Waco CG-4A Glider
During World War II, the U.S. Army Air Forces utilized military gliders as a method of delivery to battle. These one-time use, engineless aircraft were towed in pairs near to the front lines of battle, typically by a Douglas C-47 military transport aircraft, carrying troops or supplies to bolster advancing...
-
Over 100 years of bravey: The 173rd Airborne Brigade
The 173rd Airborne Brigade is a United States Army airborne infantry brigade formed on 12 June 1917 at Camp Devens, Massachusetts. It is one of the oldest airborne units in the United States Army and has a rich history of service and combat operations. A WORLD AT WAR During World...
-
War: Through the eyes of the 173rd Airborne in Afghanistan
"Brotherhood has nothing to do with feelings; it has to do with how you define your relationship to others. It has to do with the rather profound decision to put the welfare of the group above your personal welfare. In such a system, feelings are meaningless. In such a system,...
-
Into The Viper's Nest: The First Pivotal Battle Of The Afghan War
"I set out then to report this story from many points of view - American and British, from soldier to general, from diplomat to president. It seemed to me that only by getting behind the scenes could anyone pretend to understand what was happening. And it seemed far better to...
-
You can Jump from a plane. How about jumping into a book?
As paratroopers, we know you've got discipline and are always on the lookout for that new book title that will leave a lasting impression. The global library has never been more diverse, yet you want something you can relate to. The good news is that we've reached out to our...